802.1ag and Y.1731 Functional Comparison

Table: 802.1ag and Y.1731 OAM Functionality Overview lists the 802.1ag and Y.1731 OAM functions supported on the 7705 SAR. For each function and test, the table identifies the PDU that carries the test data, the test’s target entity, and the standards that the 7705 SAR supports for the test.

For example, the 7705 SAR can run an Ethernet Continuity Check using an ETH-CC test according to the dot1ag and the Y.1731 standards. For either standard, the test data is carried in a Continuity Check Message (CCM) and the test target is a MEP.

The Fault Management (FM) capabilities of ITU-T Y.1731 extend the functionality of dot1ag (ETH-CFM) with additional FM functions as well as performance monitoring (PM) capabilities. The generation of AIS and RDI messages are defined under the FM section of the Y.1731 specification, whereas Ethernet layer, delay, jitter, loss, and throughput tests are part of Y.1731 PM capabilities.

Table: Supported OAM Tests per MEP Type lists the MEPs that support each test.

Table: 802.1ag and Y.1731 OAM Functionality Overview

Test

OAM function

PDU

Target

Standard

ETH-LB

Loopback

LBM, LBR

MEP

dot1ag, Y.1731

ETH-LT

Linktrace

LTM, LTR

MEP

dot1ag, Y.1731

ETH-CC

Continuity Check

CCM

MEP

dot1ag, Y.1731

ETH-RDI

Remote Defect Indication

CCM

MEP

dot1ag, Y.1731

ETH-AIS

Alarm Indication Signal

AIS

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-LM

Frame Loss Measurement (dual-ended)

CCM

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-LM

Frame Loss Measurement (single-ended)

LMM, LMR

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-DM

Frame Delay Measurement (two-way)

DMM, DMR

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-DM

Frame Delay Measurement (one-way)

1DM

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-DV

Frame Delay Variation (one-way)

DMM, DMR

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-Test

Test Error Measurements

TST

MEP

Y.1731

ETH-SL

Synthetic Loss Measurement

SLM

MEP

dot1ag, Y.1731

Table: Supported OAM Tests per MEP Type

OAM Test

Epipe SAP Up/Down MEP

Epipe Spoke SDP Up/Down MEP

VPLS SAP Up/Down MEP

VPLS Spoke/Mesh SDP Up/Down MEP

Ethernet Network Interface Down MEP (Facility)

Loopback

Linktrace

Throughput Measurement

Continuity Check

Remote Defect Indication

Alarm Indication Signal

Test Error Measurements

Frame Delay Measurement (two-way)

Frame Delay Measurement (one-way)

Frame Delay Variation (one-way)

Frame Loss Measurement (dual-ended)

Frame Loss Measurement (single-ended)

Synthetic Loss Measurement